With two seasons on CBS, Tracker has become the network’s most-watched series, captivating audiences with its mix of weekly mysteries and gripping character drama. The show follows Colter Shaw (Justin Hartley), a rewardist who searches for missing people in exchange for monetary compensation. While fans eagerly await new episodes, there are plenty of other series that deliver similar thrills, strong characters, and compelling storylines. Here are ten excellent alternatives for Tracker fans.
Reacher (2022–) – Prime Video
Among all the comparisons, Reacher is the closest contemporary to Tracker. Both shows center on a tough, resourceful protagonist who travels to new places to help those in need. Based on the Jack Reacher novels, Alan Ritchson’s portrayal balances physical strength with an ability to connect emotionally, much like Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw.
While Reacher tells its story through longer arcs, Tracker leans into a case-of-the-week format. If you’re looking for a serialized mystery with a similar lead, Reacher is an excellent pick.
Big Sky (2020–2023) – Hulu
At first glance, Big Sky and Tracker appear very different: one focuses on private investigators in Montana, the other on a lone rewardist traveling the U.S. Yet both shows thrive on atmospheric mysteries where the landscape becomes part of the storytelling.
Big Sky uses broader story arcs, making it slower paced, but it similarly relies on its environment—whether ranches or farmhouses—to drive tension. Fans will also recognize Jensen Ackles, who appears in both series.
Will Trent (2023–) – Hulu
Like Colter Shaw, Will Trent (Ramón Rodríguez) has a complex past that shapes his work. As a Georgia Bureau of Investigation agent, he handles difficult cases across multiple counties, often clashing with local law enforcement.
Colter’s survivalist upbringing and Will’s foster care childhood both inform their unique approaches to justice. Both men are outsiders who use their unconventional experiences to solve cases others overlook.
Leverage (2008–2012) – Prime Video
Leverage offers a lighter, ensemble-driven take on the vigilante drama. The show follows a team of skilled criminals who con wealthy wrongdoers in elaborate schemes, blending drama with humor.
While Colter Shaw works independently, often skirting the law, both series highlight unconventional heroes fighting for people who can’t fight for themselves. If you enjoy clever problem-solving and weekly adventures, Leverage is a fun choice.
The Finder (2012) – Disney+
This short-lived Bones spinoff offers a flashier, more comedic version of Tracker. Starring Geoff Stults as a man with extraordinary pattern recognition skills, the series revolves around finding lost people or objects.
Though the lead’s military background differs from Colter’s, the central theme of locating the missing connects the two. Fans looking for a more lighthearted twist on the premise will appreciate The Finder.
Stumptown (2019–2020) – Apple TV (purchase)
Cobie Smulders leads Stumptown as a military veteran turned private investigator grappling with PTSD and personal loss. Like Colter, she bends rules and relies on her resilience to pursue justice.
The series blends gritty drama with wry humor, offering flawed yet relatable characters. While Stumptown is messier in tone than Tracker, fans who appreciate complex protagonists will find it compelling.
This Is Us (2016–2022) – Hulu
Though not a mystery or crime drama, This Is Us is essential viewing for fans of Justin Hartley. In this acclaimed family drama, Hartley portrays Kevin Pearson, a character very different from Colter Shaw.
Where Colter is guarded and calculated, Kevin is charismatic yet vulnerable, dealing with addiction and family struggles. Watching Hartley’s range in This Is Us offers a deeper appreciation of his performance in Tracker.
Burn Notice (2007–2013) – Hulu
For those who enjoy a mix of espionage and weekly mysteries, Burn Notice is a strong recommendation. The series follows Michael Weston (Jeffrey Donovan), a former spy abandoned by his agency and forced to survive while investigating his own betrayal.
Like Colter, Michael narrates his process, showcasing practical skills and strategies as he takes on new cases. Both characters also have complicated family dynamics that add depth to their stories.
Poker Face (2023–) – Peacock
Poker Face provides a more flamboyant spin on the procedural format. Natasha Lyonne stars as Charlie Cale, a drifter with the uncanny ability to detect lies. Each episode introduces a new town, new characters, and a fresh mystery—similar to Colter’s travels.
While Charlie’s gift sets her apart, she cannot rely on it alone, forcing her to think creatively in solving crimes. Fans of Tracker will enjoy the blend of quirky style and classic case-of-the-week storytelling.
Found (2023–2025) – Peacock
Premiering around the same time as Tracker, Found explored missing persons from a different angle. Instead of a lone investigator, it followed a dedicated team in one city, all personally connected to abduction or disappearance.
Though canceled after two seasons, Found delivered layered stories with complex motivations behind each case. Like Tracker, it explored how past trauma shapes present choices while balancing legal, technological, and law enforcement partnerships.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re drawn to lone wolves like Colter Shaw or ensemble casts tackling mysteries together, there’s no shortage of engaging shows to explore while waiting for Tracker’s return. From the grit of Reacher to the heart of This Is Us, these series offer suspense, drama, and unforgettable characters that will keep you hooked.
