Following its explosive debut in early 2024, Tracker quickly cemented itself as one of the year’s most popular television shows. Based on Jeff Deaver's Colter Shaw series, the Justin Hartley-led procedural captivated audiences with its blend of mystery, intrigue, and compelling characters. With season 2 already confirmed after just four episodes, fans are eagerly anticipating what comes next for Colter Shaw and the mysteries he uncovers. This time around, five key female characters will shape the upcoming season’s narrative, pushing Colter’s journey to new depths.
While Colter Shaw, portrayed by Hartley, remains the central character, the second season will focus heavily on the women in his life—each with their own secrets and influence on the overarching mystery. Season 1 laid the groundwork for these characters, and as Colter searches for answers, their stories will intertwine with his in profound and unexpected ways.
Mary Dove Shaw (Wendy Crewson) – The Mysterious Matriarch
Colter’s mother, Mary Dove Shaw, will play a pivotal role in season 2, adding complexity to the mystery surrounding her late husband. First introduced in season 1, Mary Dove’s actions hinted that she is hiding crucial information. Her reluctance to share details about her husband’s past and a suspicious break-in at her home suggest deeper secrets yet to be revealed.
Season 1 left viewers questioning Mary Dove’s true intentions, and Colter’s interactions with her in season 2 are bound to be filled with tension. As Colter seeks more information about his father, Mary Dove's evasive nature and possible hidden motives will propel much of the season’s drama.
Dorian Shaw (Melissa Roxburgh) – The Dismissive Sister
Colter’s younger sister, Dorian "Dory" Shaw, was introduced later in the first season, and her cold dismissal of their father’s past created friction between her and Colter. As a professor in Wyoming, Dory has a sharp intellect, but her refusal to discuss their father’s involvement with the law—and her secret correspondence with their brother Russell—raises questions about her loyalty.
Dory's evasiveness in season 1 left much to be desired, but her role in season 2 promises to be far more substantial. As Colter digs deeper into his father’s mysterious death, Dory will need to explain her actions and reveal why she kept key information hidden from her brother. Her motivations will be critical to unlocking the truth.
Lizzy Hawking (Jennifer Morrison) – The Honest Family Friend
In a shocking season finale reveal, family friend Lizzy Hawking delivered bombshell information to Colter about his father’s secret affair and possible involvement in criminal activity. As someone who knew Colter’s father well, Lizzy could be the key to solving the overarching mystery that has haunted Colter since his father’s death.
With Jennifer Morrison confirmed to return, Lizzy’s honesty and willingness to help Colter stands in stark contrast to the secrecy within the Shaw family. Lizzy’s knowledge could give Colter the answers he needs—if he can fully trust her.
Billie Matalon (Sofia Pernas) – The Romantic Rival
Billie Matalon, a fellow reward-seeker and a romantic interest for Colter, will return in season 2 to complicate both his professional and personal life. Introduced as a competitor, Billie has a complicated history with Colter, having previously conned him. Despite this, their chemistry is undeniable.
Billie’s reappearance promises to reignite tension and unresolved feelings between the two. Her experience and cunning could prove invaluable in Colter’s quest, but her motives may not always align with his. Will Billie help or hinder Colter’s search for truth?
Reenie Green (Fiona Rene) – The Legal Powerhouse
Rounding out the influential women in Colter’s life is Reenie Green, the legal expert who played a crucial role in season 1. As the team’s go-to lawyer, Reenie helped Colter out of several tight spots, but her decision to quit her job at the end of the season leaves room for speculation about her future role in the series.
With her legal expertise and close ties to Colter’s team, Reenie's involvement in season 2 is likely to intensify. Now that she has more freedom, she may become an even more integral part of Colter’s operations, perhaps even transforming the team dynamic.
Conclusion
As Tracker gears up for its second season, these five women will bring fresh perspectives, conflict, and revelations to the storyline. Whether through family drama, romantic entanglements, or hidden secrets, their influence on Colter Shaw’s journey will be undeniable. With these complex characters driving the narrative forward, season 2 promises even greater intrigue and emotional stakes. Fans can expect Tracker to continue blending intense mysteries with rich character development as Colter navigates the dangerous path ahead—guided, in large part, by the women in his life.
