As Tracker Season 1 wraps up, fans of high-octane action and heartfelt drama are already speculating about the next season. But for fans of NBC's beloved series This Is Us, there’s another hope brewing—could we see some familiar faces from the Pearson family tree pop up in Tracker Season 2? After all, This Is Us had a way of making its audience deeply care about its characters, and Tracker could benefit from bringing some of that emotional depth to its action-packed narrative.
Here are eight This Is Us cast members we’d love to see in Tracker Season 2.
1. Sterling K. Brown (Randall Pearson)
Sterling K. Brown's Emmy-winning portrayal of Randall Pearson captivated audiences with his emotional range, strength, and vulnerability. Imagine that same presence in Tracker, playing a mentor or a high-level government official who could serve as a moral compass to the show’s main character, played by Justin Hartley. Brown’s intensity would bring gravitas to any situation, adding emotional weight to the series' fast-paced narrative.
2. Milo Ventimiglia (Jack Pearson)
Milo Ventimiglia’s iconic portrayal of Jack Pearson made him the ultimate father figure. In Tracker, his charisma could translate well into a more rugged role—perhaps as a retired military officer or a seasoned investigator who has a personal stake in a mission. Ventimiglia excels at playing characters who are deeply empathetic but tough as nails when it counts, making him a perfect fit for Tracker's world of danger and suspense.
3. Mandy Moore (Rebecca Pearson)
Mandy Moore proved her dramatic chops as Rebecca Pearson, capturing the heart and soul of This Is Us for six seasons. In Tracker, Moore could take on a role that contrasts her motherly figure—a savvy and resourceful character on the run, or perhaps someone connected to an international conspiracy. Moore’s range would allow her to embody the vulnerability and strength needed for such a role, offering a different shade of her acting abilities.
4. Chrissy Metz (Kate Pearson)
Chrissy Metz's portrayal of Kate Pearson was all about resilience, vulnerability, and growth. In Tracker, she could play a key ally to Hartley’s character—perhaps a tech genius or an intelligence officer who aids in the tracking of high-profile criminals. Metz’s ability to bring emotional authenticity to her roles would be a great counterbalance to the action-heavy sequences, grounding the show in heartfelt moments.
5. Chris Sullivan (Toby Damon)
Chris Sullivan brought comic relief and emotional depth to This Is Us as Toby Damon. In Tracker, he could take on a lighter role, providing the humor needed in a tension-filled show. But don’t underestimate his range—Sullivan could also tackle a darker, more dramatic part, perhaps as a mysterious informant with a complicated past. His versatility makes him an intriguing addition to the Tracker universe.
6. Susan Kelechi Watson (Beth Pearson)
As Beth Pearson, Susan Kelechi Watson embodied strength, grace, and resilience. In Tracker, Watson could step into the role of a high-ranking intelligence officer or a tough-as-nails undercover agent. Her fierce determination as Beth would translate beautifully into the world of international intrigue, giving the show a powerful female presence capable of holding her own in a male-dominated environment.
7. Jon Huertas (Miguel Rivas)
Jon Huertas, who played Miguel Rivas in This Is Us, could easily transition into Tracker as a seasoned operative or an international criminal mastermind. Huertas’ natural charisma and quiet intensity would make him a formidable adversary or ally. He’s proven he can handle complex characters, and Tracker would give him the opportunity to play a role with even more mystery and intrigue.
8. Ron Cephas Jones (William Hill)
Though William Hill’s arc in This Is Us was tragic and touching, Ron Cephas Jones' ability to bring soulful gravitas to his characters cannot be overlooked. In Tracker, Jones could portray a former mentor or a crucial informant with ties to the underground world. His screen presence is undeniable, and having him on board would add a layer of emotional depth to any storyline.
With Justin Hartley leading Tracker, it only makes sense to tap into the This Is Us talent pool for more captivating performances. These actors, already proven to have remarkable chemistry and dramatic range, would be the perfect fit to elevate the series. Whether they step in as allies, adversaries, or complex figures with their own agendas, This Is Us alumni could make Tracker Season 2 unmissable for fans of both shows.
Only time will tell if any of these casting dreams come true, but one thing’s for sure—viewers would be thrilled to see the Pearson family back on their screens, even in a whole new context.
