Why Tracker Is So Popular On CBS Despite Divisive Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score

The new CBS show Tracker is one of the most-watched programs on television following its premiere after the Super Bowl on February 11, but the audience reviews tell a different story. The action drama, created by Ben H. Winters, is loosely based on Jeffery Deaver's 2019 novel The Never GameTracker revolves around Colter Shaw, played by Justin Hartley of This Is Us fame, a skilled survivalist who travels across the country to help law enforcement rescue missing people (and gets rewarded for doing so). Since its second episode, Tracker has gained viewers, significantly increasing its popularity.

Each episode of Tracker features Hartley's Colter Shaw traveling to a new town to take on a job. He gets hired to use his expert tracking skills to locate people who have disappeared, sometimes butting heads with the local police. However, Colter also has a mysterious and traumatic past that shaped him into the man he is in the present. The CBS series often weaves flashbacks of Colter's childhood throughout the episodes to slowly but surely piece together the puzzle that is Colter Shaw.

Tracker's Ratings Explained: Why It's One Of The Biggest Network TV Shows Right Now

Tracker Is The Most Watched Scripted Show On Network TV

 

Justin Hartley in a scene from the CBS show Tracker

Colter Shaw with a gun in Tracker

Justin Hartley in Tracker episode 1

Colter reading a clue in Tracker

Justin Hartley talking to someone as Colter Shaw in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Justin Hartley in a scene from the CBS show Tracker

Colter Shaw with a gun in Tracker

Justin Hartley in Tracker episode 1

Colter reading a clue in Tracker

Justin Hartley talking to someone as Colter Shaw in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Episode #

Episode Title

Viewers (millions)

18-49 Demo

1

"Klamath Falls"

18.44

3.94

2

"Missoula"

6.87

0.46

3

"Springfield"

7.12

0.48

4

"Mt. Shasta"

7.61

0.50

5

"St. Louis"

7.55

0.47

6

"Lexington"

7.28

0.54

7

"Chicago"

6.8

0.54

8

"Camden"

8.19

0.56

9

"Aurora"

7.6

0.42

10

"Into the Wild"

7.7

0.45

Justin Hartley's role as the main character in the cast of Tracker certainly helps boost its ratings, given his previous acclaimed projects (like This Is Us). Plus, the CBS action drama debuted after Super Bowl LVIII (which was the most-watched television program of all time in the United States), forcing several to watch it and get sucked into the story. Ultimately, Tracker's promotion during the Super Bowl and its cast and intriguing premise contributed to the show's high ratings. According to TV Series Finale, the viewership totals and Nielsen demo ratings for the released episodes of Tracker season 1 are:

Not only is Tracker the most-watched new series in the 2023–2024 seasons, it is also the most-watched network television show overall. Tracker performs better than established dramas like Grey's AnatomyNCIS, and Chicago Fire and popular sitcoms such as Young Sheldon and Ghosts. Consequently, CBS renewed Tracker for season 2 less than a month after its premiere, with only four episodes released.

Why Tracker's Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score Is So Divided When It's So Popular

Tracker Has A 62% Audience Score On Rotten Tomatoes

 

Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Wendy Crewson as Mary Dove Shaw in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Fiona Rene as Reenie in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Robin Weigert as Teddi Bruin in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Abby McEnany as Velma Bruin in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Wendy Crewson as Mary Dove Shaw in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Fiona Rene as Reenie in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Robin Weigert as Teddi Bruin in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Abby McEnany as Velma Bruin in Tracker season 1, episode 1.

Remaining Tracker Season 1 Episode #'s

Episode Title

Director

Writer

Release Date

11

"Beyond the Campus Walls"

Joel Novoa

Travis Donnelly

May 5, 2024

12

"Off the Books"

TBA

TBA

May 12, 2024

13

"The Storm"

Ken Olin

Elwood Reid and Sharon Lee Watson

May 19, 2024

Even though Tracker is currently the hottest show on television, Justin Hartley's new network drama series has an average Audience Score on Rotten Tomatoes. As of the writing of this article, the Audience Score sits at 62 percent, averaged from more than 50 ratings. The CBS action drama is considered "Fresh," but it's toying the line between "Fresh" and "Rotten," at least concerning viewers' reviews. Some commend Tracker for its complex cast of entertaining characters and compelling stories, while others feel that the show is far-fetched and poorly written.

Based on the reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, those who watch Tracker either love or hate it as there is no in-between, which accounts for its average Audience Score. Of course, Rotten Tomatoes only reflects a small fraction of viewers' opinions on the CBS television series, and according to the ratings, more people seem to enjoy it than despise it. But it's still intriguing to see the viewers being so divisive on the review-aggregation website.

What Critics Have Said About Tracker

Tracker Has A Great Tomatometer Score

 

Colter Shaw gestures with his hands in a close up from Tracker season 1

Robin Weigert as Teddi Bruin in Tracker.

Justin Hartley and John Huertas on the set of Tracker.

Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw and Gavin Russo as Robert Moloney look at photos in Tracker.

A close up of Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw in Tracker.

Colter Shaw gestures with his hands in a close up from Tracker season 1

Robin Weigert as Teddi Bruin in Tracker.

Justin Hartley and John Huertas on the set of Tracker.

Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw and Gavin Russo as Robert Moloney look at photos in Tracker.

A close up of Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw in Tracker.

Tracker Cast

Character

Justin Hartley

Colter Shaw

Robin Weigert

Teddi Bruin

Abby McEnany

Velma Bruin

Eric Graise

Bob Exley

Fiona Rene

Reenie

Lee Tergesen

Ashton Shaw

Wendy Crewson

Mary Dove Shaw

Melissa Roxburgh

Dory Shaw

Jensen Ackles

Russell Shaw

Despite Tracker's suspiciously low Audience Score on Rotten Tomatoes, its Tomatometer is impressive — 88 percent based on 17 reviews from critics. How critics rated the CBS action drama is obviously much more positive than how audiences felt. While critics' reviews aren't all that matters when assessing a show's success, praise certainly helps a series gain viewers. The Critics Consensus reads:

"Making great use of Justin Hartley's swaggering appeal, Tracker takes a spartan approach to a classic formula and yields a highly efficient entertainment."

Critics applauded Hartley's work as the charming star (and producer) of Tracker, while also praising the show for its compelling cases, entertainment value, and room for growth. The positive reviews mixed with the outrageous viewership totals indicate that CBS has another hit drama series on its hands, and the network has wisely committed to making the show great so that its success could last for a long time. Hopefully, Tracker season 2 will perform as well as (or surpass the achievements of) season 1.

Sources: TV Series FinaleRotten Tomatoes

Related Posts

SHOCKING — Tracker Season 2 Finale Unveils Dark Family Secrets and Sets Up a Gripping Season 3

The intense finale of Tracker Season 2, titled “Echo Ridge,” delivered a stunning emotional punch by taking lead character Colter Shaw (Justin Hartley) back to his childhood…

JAW-DROPPING — Tracker Season 2 Finale Review: Major Answers Delivered and a Thrilling Cliffhanger Set for Season 3

Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for Tracker season 2, episode 20 Tracker has had something of an inconsistent second season – but the season 2 finale, "Echo…

MIND-BLOWING — After Tracker Season 2, Doubts Arise About Colter Shaw’s Effectiveness in His Role

Many agree that Tracker season 2 couldn't live up to the high expectations set by season 1, and accordingly, Colter Shaw couldn't live up to his "skilled…

JAW-DROPPING — Tracker Season 2 Episode 17 Review: A Twist-Filled Episode That Raises More Questions Than Answers

Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for Tracker season 2, episode 17 This week, Tracker switches up the focus on supporting characters. It makes for a fantastic episode…

SHOCKING — Why ‘Tracker’ Season 3 Must Finally End This Troubling Trend

Though I'm someone who usually appreciates dark and heavy storylines, even I have to admit: Tracker season 3 needs to dial it back. Tracker season 2 wrapped…

FANS ARE DIVIDED — How One Major Addition Turned ‘Tracker’ Season 2 Into a Must-Watch Show

We can all agree that Tracker season 2 couldn't live up to the high standard set by season 1, but one aspect of the newer episodes showcased…